Dem Lawyers Say: Give Florida & Michigan Half Their Delegates

Seen in the New York Times:

Democratic Party lawyers have determined that no more than half the delegates from Florida and Michigan can be seated at the party’s August convention, dealing a blow to Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton’s efforts to seat the full delegations from those states.[...]

In asking that the full delegations from these states be seated, Mrs. Clinton hopes to narrow Senator Barack Obama’s delegate edge and make the case that by including the votes from these states, she will have more of the popular vote in the nominating contests, an assertion that has come under some dispute. But the legal analysis, based on party rules and contained in a 38-page memo to the committee, says the committee can either seat only 50 percent of the delegates or seat them all but give them only half a vote, which amounts to the same thing.

Letting Michigan and Florida delegates cast half-votes, the same sort of penalty that’s being imposed by the GOP for the states’ decision to have their primaries so ridiculously early, is actually the most sensible compromise in my mind, if only because it’s half way between “the rules are the rules” and the strategic folly of not seating the delegations from two potentially large swing states.

The rules committee is meeting Saturday, and the pundits think a decision will be made that day.  Personally, I think it would be more strategically appropriate to withhold a ruling until late next week — after the final primaries have been held, and undeclared superdelegates have an opportunity to chime in.

The way Obama’s been collecting superdelegates recently, if the rules committee postponed their decision, it’s entirely possible that the outcome of the primary season could be cleanly settled, without having to touch the question of Florida and Michigan.   If that were the case, any decision could be rendered moot, allowing for easier compromise.

With the potential of a 31 May ruling…well, the Dems have a shot at looking more like their nominee is being determined by party bigwigs in the (admittedly semi-transparent) back room….an image the D’s should be shying away from, unless they really are trying to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.